| Scott Amspaugh | EUM | Phil Frech/Bill Stock |
| Steve Hellwarth | Alethia Christian | Keith and Betsy Berger |
| Ryan Holscher | EUM | Phil and Jessica Frech |
| Allen Keaser | | James Mann |
| Dean Richardson | EUM | Ryan and Cheryl Riffell |
| Gabriel Richardson | EUM | Mitchell and Patti Cheadle |
| Chase Simmerman | New Pointe Community | Katie and Chris Hammaker |
| Phil Strait | EUM | Ryan and Cheryl Riffell |
| Michael Williams | Community of Faith | Tawni Williams and Dan Hicks |
| Brian Claywell | Covenant of Peace | Ken and Teri Sowinski |
| Anthony Purdin | Wesley United Methodist Church | Kevin Lawrence |
| Stephen Garber | EUM | Pat Rosenbeck |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | |
